If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, Rolling Stone may receive an affiliate commission.

Shopping for an at-home carpet cleaner can quickly get overwhelming. Between Shark’s StainStriker, Black + Decker’s Flex 3-in-1 Stick Vacuum, Tineco’s Carpet One Cruiser, and the Bissell Big Green Machine, there’s no shortage of choices — just a shortage of time (and patience) to compare them all.

To make things easier for you, we put two of the most talked-about models to the test, the Tineco Carpet One Cruiser and the Bissell Big Green Machine, to determine which one is the best.

We looked at how each cleaner performs, what kinds of messes they’re best at tackling, and whether their price tags actually match their results. The Tineco retails for $699, while the Bissell comes in at $411. If you’re trying to figure out which one is right for your space and your budget, read on for the full breakdown and our final verdict.

Tineco Carpet One Cruiser vs Bissell Big Green Machine: Design and Construction

The Tineco Carpet One Cruiser and the Bissell Big Green Machine share a similar upright design, but that’s about where the similarities end. The Tineco stands out for its sleek, compact build. It features a clear gallon tank, which not only lets you monitor progress in real-time but also makes cleaning oddly satisfying (think TikTok ASMR) — a comfortable handle and smooth-rolling wheels. Living in a small New York City apartment, I found it easy to store, and thanks to its stationary dock, it looks like a cool, modern home gadget when left out. There are no eyesores here.

The Bissell Big Green Machine, on the other hand, has a much bulkier design. It’s harder to tuck away, the handle feels less ergonomic, and its opaque tank makes it hard to judge how much cleaning you’ve done. That said, its size gives it a heavy-duty feel — it looks and performs like it’s built to handle serious messes. Both machines are straightforward to set up, but when it comes to overall aesthetics and storage, the Tineco has a clear edge.

Tineco Carpet One Cruiser vs Bissell Big Green Machine: Features and Controls

The Tineco Carpet One Cruiser is about as advanced as it gets (in terms of carpet cleaners). It features multiple cleaning modes, including what Tineco calls “Smart Sensor Technology,” which utilizes a color-changing LED light to detect the level of dirtiness in an area and then automatically adjusts the cleaning intensity accordingly. It’s a sharp, hands-off experience that takes the guesswork out of household maintenance.

One of Tineco’s biggest standout features is the built-in drying mode. Underneath the unit, there’s a mechanism that functions a bit like a hair dryer for your floor, removing moisture and preventing that damp, musty aftermath some machines leave behind. For someone like me, who doesn’t have the patience to wait for carpets to dry (and has learned the hard way about how this can cause unwanted odors), this feature was a game-changer.

By comparison, the Bissell Big Green Machine is more old-school. It doesn’t offer smart sensors or automatic adjustments, so it’s up to you to decide how much cleaning each area needs. That can easily lead to over-saturating certain spots. It also lacks a drying mode, meaning you’ll have to rely on air-drying or go the manual route with towels, which is less efficient and definitely more work.

Both the Tineco and Bissell machines are versatile and come with attachments for hard-to-reach areas, which is especially helpful for pet owners. They can be used on carpets, upholstery, and more. I was genuinely impressed by how well both lifted old stains. I have a golden retriever who specializes in tracking dirt and mystery substances into the apartment (photo of the mud-covered culprit below). Both machines handled paw prints, dried drool (sorry for the visual), and the usual New York City grime after a day in Central Park.

It’s worth noting that both the Tineco Carpet One Cruiser and the Bissell Big Green Machine require an outlet to operate. If you’re looking for a cordless option, Bissell does offer a battery-powered version you can check out here.

Tineco Carpet One Cruiser vs Bissell Big Green Machine: Ease and Usability

This is the category where the distinctions between the Tineco Carpet One Cruiser and the Bissell Big Green Machine were really clear. Tineco’s model weighs in at under 25 pounds, and you can feel it. It’s lightweight, easy to maneuver, and glides effortlessly forward and backward, thanks to its smooth wheel design. As someone with a not-so-great lower back (shoutout to 24 years of professional dance), this made a huge difference. I could clean multiple rooms without feeling like I needed to pop about 15 Advil afterward.

The Carpet One Cruiser also performed well across a variety of surfaces. I tested it on four different carpets, including nylon and polyester materials, and it cleaned them all with the same consistency and power. I was initially skeptical about how it would work on upholstered furniture, given its upright build, but it handled my couch like a pro, with no awkward angles and no sweat required. The machine is genuinely intuitive, and it’s clear it was designed to be user-friendly from the start.

It also gets bonus points for the self-cleaning mode: after emptying the dirty water (“Boston, you’re my home”) tank, the Tineco handles the internal cleanup itself. This not only saves time but also helps prevent mold or bacterial buildup, which is something you don’t want lurking inside a machine meant to clean your home.

The Bissell Big Green Machine, true to its name, is big. It weighs around 40 pounds and feels every bit of it. Maneuvering it requires more effort, especially on uneven surfaces or when using the attachments. I found myself having to really apply pressure during cleaning to get the same level of effectiveness. If you have any mobility issues or chronic pain, this could be a dealbreaker.

That said, with some trial and error, I got better at using it, figuring out where to lean in and how much force to apply. But it’s not as plug-and-play as the Tineco. The Bissell also lacks a self-cleaning mode, which means you’ll need to thoroughly rinse and maintain it yourself after each use to keep it in good shape.

Tineco Carpet One Cruiser vs Bissell Big Green Machine: Final Verdict

Here’s the bottom line: both the Tineco Carpet One Cruiser and the Bissell Big Green Machine deliver efficient and effective cleaning. In other words, they both live up to their viral hype. But the Tineco pulls ahead in ease of use. It’s lighter, smarter, and packed with high-tech features that make the whole experience feel effortless. It’s the type of cleaner where you can see and feel the difference each time.

If you’re looking for a sleek, advanced machine that practically runs itself (and you don’t mind spending a bit more), the Tineco is the way to go. On the other hand, if you want a reliable, heavy-duty cleaner and prioritize performance over polish, the Bissell Big Green is a solid, more budget-friendly pick.